[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Bypassing Facebook on the dark web

Bannon, Salvini, And A Powerful Catholic Cardinal Are Gunning For Pope Francis

DOJ requests military lawyers to help prosecute immigration crimes: report

Canada legalizes marijuana, sales to start on October 17

Will the Real Donald Trump Please Stand Up?

WHY CAN’T WE SUE THE TSA FOR ASSAULT?

WATCH VIDEO: Muslim calls flight attendant a ‘fucking slut*’ and a ‘bitch for serving him what he thinks is pork – “She should have respected my religion”

James Comey And Peter Strzok Walk Into A Courtroom And Meet The America They Sold Out

Barack Obama: Liar And Nation Wrecker

Islamic Takeover Of America!

What Trump Gets Right About Europe

America the beautiful

"I'm 81 and I'm Tired"

Rachel Maddow Breaks Down in Tears Delivering News of Migrant Babies Being Detained

Disability Applications Plunge as the Economy Strengthens

Nazi Media or MSM as we know them

'Disastrous' copyright bill vote approved

Google Is Training Machines to Predict When a Patient Will Die

Tariffs Will Wipe Out the Benefits of Tax Reform

Study Confirms Most Psychopaths Live in Washington D.C.

Can Police Arrest Person Carrying Gun Without First Checking If He's Licensed? |

Why America’s Trade War With China Will Be Absolutely Crippling For The U.S. Economy

Mainstream Media Confirms "Conspiracy Theory" That Walmart Stores Are Being Turned into Prison Camps

AMA Says Take Your Meds While Doctors Take Your Guns

Wealthy Asians Are Getting Richer Faster Than Anyone Else

Government Eyes Are Watching You: We Are All Prisoners of the Surveillance State

Taxation=Theft

Why Can't We Sue the TSA For Assault?

HIT & RUN BLOG Trump Announces Plans for a 'Space Force.' Seriously

Cop Threatens to Kill an Innocent Man, Murder his Mom Too—Not Fired

Black woman declares ... 'I hate white people' --- before attacking Ride On bus passengers

James Hansen wishes he wasn't so right about global warming

More Revolutionaries Are Coming

9/11: The Greatest Gift the Status Quo Ever Got

How Trump's Republican Party Went Soft on Communism

FATHER’S DAY: Bill Clinton ‘son’ calls for ‘dad’ to take paternity test

Local Complementarian Lets Female Police Officer Off With A Warning

Kim Jong Un Criticized For Meeting With Nation That Has Killed 60 Million Babies

Salon Writer Recommends Shunning Friends and Family Who Support Trump

GOP will hit FBI, DOJ with 'full arsenal of constitutional weapons' if they don't comply with subpoena, Gowdy warns

Ted Cruz Beats Jimmy Kimmel in Charity Basketball Game

Judge Who Jailed Manafort Also Cleared Hillary Clinton In Benghazi Case

TV Poll: 71% of Liberals Don’t Want Peace With North Korea Because Trump Would Take Credit

Trump Says Comey 'Totally Protected Hillary' but Was Fired for Actions That Hurt Her

We Are All Bigots

Trump partly right on Canada's dairy tariffs

BLM Agents Open Fire on Innocent Couple, Shoot Woman Because ATV Drove Near Restricted Area

Maine: Man Dies After Brutal Beating By Muslim Migrant Mob In Lewiston Park

FBI AGENTS CALLED HILLARY “PRESIDENT” WHILE INVESTIGATING HER, TEXTED “SCREW YOU TRUMP” ON ELECTION DAY

White House Reporters Become Unglued Over Border Enforcement


Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

Health/Medical
See other Health/Medical Articles

Title: President Trump Needs To Stop Breaking The Law Over Obamacare Like Obama Did
Source: The Federalist
URL Source: http://thefederalist.com/2017/08/15 ... king-law-obamacare-like-obama/
Published: Aug 15, 2017
Author: Christopher Jacobs
Post Date: 2017-08-16 08:22:50 by Tooconservative
Keywords: None
Views: 204
Comments: 2

Over the last several months, this space has highlighted that President Trump has an opportunity and a challenge: Restoring the constitutional rule of law his predecessor often ignored. Such a move would require ending the Obama administration’s ad hoc rewriting of Obamacare, implementing the law as written—no more, no less.

Into that debate stepped the Conservative Action Project on Friday, with a memo noting that the president can and should lead on Obamacare. The title suggests a continuation of Obama’s “pen and a phone” mentality, emphasizing executive unilateralism in the face of Congress’ inability to pass “repeal-and-replace” legislation regarding Obamacare.

So Far Trump Is Perpetuating Obama’s Law-Breaking

The document contains numerous important suggestions to undo President Obama’s illegal executive acts. For instance, it encourages Trump to “take action to end the illegal and unconstitutional cost-sharing subsidies to the insurance companies,” ending their disbursement. This development would be not only welcome, but far overdue.

For more than six months President Trump has continued his predecessor’s habit of violating the Constitution to disburse billions of unappropriated dollars to insurance companies. To both enforce the rule of law and end crony capitalist dealings between “Big Government” and “Big Insurance,” Trump should end the unconstitutional subsidies forthwith.

The CAP letter also rightly calls on Trump to “end the illegal diversion of money from the U.S. Treasury to insurance companies.” The Government Accountability Office ruled last September that the Obama administration had violated the text of Obamacare by prioritizing reinsurance payments to insurers over required payments to the Treasury. As with the cost-sharing subsidies, President Trump should put the rule of law—and taxpayers—ahead of insurance companies’ special interests.

The CAP document calls for President Trump to “continue to fight for repeal of the individual mandate,” but—thankfully—does not call for Trump to defang the mandate unilaterally. As I wrote back in January, when administration officials first suggested they may not enforce the mandate at all, “a Republican Administration should not be tempted to ‘use unilateral actions to achieve conservative ends.’ Such behavior represents a contradiction in terms.”

You Can’t Ignore the Law Because You Don’t Like It

In this same vein, CAP’s call for the Trump administration to “expand the exemption for so-called ‘grandmothered’ plans” represents an open invitation for the president to violate the Constitution, just as his predecessor did. These “grandmothered” plans should have been cancelled in January 2014, as they did not—and do not—comply with the new statutory requirements included in Obamacare.

In late 2013, President Obama faced political controversy for his “If you like your plan, you can keep it” broken promise, which became PolitiFact’s Lie of the Year. To stanch his political bleeding and solve the problem of millions of cancellation notices—along with a broken website preventing individuals with cancelled plans from buying new ones—Obama tried to pass the proverbial buck. He said his administration would allow states, if they chose, to let individuals keep their plans—temporarily. This purportedly “temporary” solution has been extended numerous times, and now is scheduled to expire at the end of 2018.

Unfortunately, as law professor (and Obamacare supporter) Nicholas Bagley has noted, Obama’s unilateral creation of these “grandmothered” health plans violated his constitutional duties as chief executive: “The Administration thus used the public pronouncements of its non-enforcement policies to encourage the regulated community to disregard provisions of [the law]. Prospectively licensing large groups of people to violate a congressional statute for policy reasons is inimical to the Take Care clause.”

To put it more bluntly, the president cannot decline to enforce the law because he finds himself in a political jam, whether due to a broken promise, a non-functioning website, or mere disagreement with the law in question. That principle applies as equally to President Trump as it does to President Obama. Trump’s extension of “grandmothered” plans violates the Constitution as much as President Obama’s did—and expanding those plans to include other forms of insurance would represent a further violation.

To be clear, as a matter of policy, I hate the idea of cancelling millions of insurance policies because they do not meet Obamacare’s myriad regulatory requirements. But as I noted recently, I believe President Trump should do just that—not because I support that outcome, or because President Trump supports it, but because the law requires it. He should have done that months ago—within days of taking office—to make clear that the cancellations stemmed from President Obama’s violation of his own health law, not any measure Trump himself wanted to implement.

Unfortunately, however, President Trump has yet to enforce the law, or the Constitution, when it comes to Obamacare, having undone none of his predecessor’s illegal and extralegal acts. For this conservative, hope springs eternal, as tomorrow always brings another opportunity to do the right thing. Here’s to this administration finally realizing that the rule of law by definition means enforcing the laws one disagrees with—for that critical principle exceeds the value of any particular law, no matter how onerous or obscure.


Poster Comment:

Trump needs to stop enabling the law-breaking of 0bama and Congress.

They want 0bamaCare? Trump needs to cram every last word up their hineys sideways.

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

#1. To: Tooconservative (#0)

"implementing the law as written"

Why? The U.S. Supreme Court didn't. The law, as written, called the individual mandate a "fine". As written. But the court said it was a tax.

So right away we're off to a lousy start. But NOW we should implement the law as written?

misterwhite  posted on  2017-08-16   10:27:48 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#2. To: misterwhite (#1)

So right away we're off to a lousy start. But NOW we should implement the law as written?

Sure. Go back and enforce all those phony unlawful exemptions that businesses like McDonalds and many others got. They got an 0bama exemption but it has no force of law. Trump should collect fines from all of them.

That's only the beginning of what Trump could do.

He could force a repeal of 0bamaCare doing this, I think. Or force the Senate to actually fix it and do it the way he wants it done.

Tooconservative  posted on  2017-08-16   12:43:55 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Please report web page problems, questions and comments to webmaster@libertysflame.com