[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Feds: Coast Guard lieutenant compiled hit list of lawmakers

Supreme Court Delivers Unanimous Victory for Asset Forfeiture Challenge (Ruth Bader Ginsburg)

Johnny Versus The News Man

Suspect thought dog was spying for police, charges in Jefferson County animal abuse case say

This Will Make You Question Everything (Don't be manipulated)

STOP Pussyfooting Around! Just Call Socialism What it REALLY IS!!

Smollett Pleaded No Contest In 2007 To Providing False Information To Law Enforcement

"I’m Committing Professional Suicide": CBS Star Reporter Admits "Mostly Liberal" Journalists Are Now "Political Activists"

Boy called 'Little Hitler' for using hot chocolate stand to raise money for border wall, parents say

You may soon have to give your DNA to the state and pay $250 for the privilege

State House Passes Major Rights-Supporting Bill—Outlawing DUI Checkpoints

After Innocent Couple Murdered Over Cop’s Lies, Houston Police Vow No More No-Knock Raids

Trump Administration Launches Global Effort to End Criminalization of Homosexuality

NoT ... long --- To live

Vatican laicizes disgraced ex-cardinal Theodore McCarrick

Trump’s Alarming Abuse of Executive Power

How "1984" turned into an instruction manual

Rule by Fiat: National Crises, Fake Emergencies and Other Dangerous Presidential Powers

Former CIA Officer Exposes Clinton Charity Fraud As Biggest Scandal In US History

11-Year-old Boy Visited by Cops After Neighbors Reported Him For Selling Hot Chocolate ("See Something, Say Something")

Houston Narc Who Lied to Justify a Deadly Drug Raid Had Been Accused of Perjury

AMERICA’S NEWEST MUSLIM MARTYR IS A CHILD RAPIST AND KILLER

Sharpton Calls for Smollett to ‘Face Accountability to the Maximum’ if He Staged Hoax

Faggoty Looking ANTIFA Member Gets Knocked Out By Conservative In Portland

NATIONAL EMERGENCY: Trump's Executive Orders To Destroy Deep State Criminal Cabal

Eyeing 2020, Biden Criticizes Trump E , Biden Criticizes Trump in Europe: ‘This Too Shall Pass; We Will Be Back’ Europe:

Has Trump wrecked our sex life? "Post-Trump Sex Disorder" is real, says sex therapist

Hoda Muthana 'deeply regrets' joining Isis and wants to return home

The TSA's Secret Watchlist for Travelers Who Don't Kowtow

Ann Coulter Fires Back at Trump: ‘The Only National Emergency Is That Our President Is an Idiot’

The deeper reason for drug ads on television

Drug convictions overturned for 10 framed by Chicago police sergeant: 'He took everything from me'

CONFUSION: Pelosi wishes ‘Happy Thanksgiving’— on — on Valentine’s Day

5 insane provisions in the amnesty omnibus bill

Cops Admit to Lying About Raid that Left Innocent Couple Murdered

Reports Claim Jussie Smollet Allegedly Staged Hate Crime Attack; Police Say News Is 'Unconfirmed, Inaccurate’

C.I. Whose Heroin Buy Led to a Deadly Houston Drug Raid Does Not Seem to Exist

Terry Kath - The little-known rock guitarist who was 'better' than Jimi Hendrix

Nancy Pelosi Earned Fortune on IPO Stock Through ‘Illegal’ Insider Trading

George Soros says Europe faces ‘oblivion’ as pro-freedom parties set to win big in European election

US Air Freight Company that Smuggled Weapons Into Venezuela Linked to CIA "Black Site" Renditions

The Democrat-Communist Party Isn't Going To Like This

‘Shameful & disgusting!’ TSA slammed for ‘invasive groping’ of triple-amputee US veteran

Trump’s Absurd Claim that Americans Are Free from Government Coercion

It is the right and duty of all Americans to REFUSE to comply with unconstitutional gun laws

The pope and Islam’s most important imam just signed a covenant that pushes us much closer to a One World Religion

There’s Nothing Ridiculous About Trains Replacing Planes

Study Shows Concealed Carry Permit Holders Break Laws Far Less Than Cops

US Company That Smuggled Weapons Into Venezuela Linked to CIA “Black Site” Renditions

Tasered 11 Times Over Turn Signal


Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

U.S. Constitution
See other U.S. Constitution Articles

Title: Supreme Court Fallout: Calif. Teachers Sue Unions to Recoup Unconstitutional 'Agency Fees'
Source: PJMedia
URL Source: https://pjmedia.com/trending/suprem ... -unconstitutional-agency-fees/
Published: Jul 7, 2018
Author: Tyler O'Neil
Post Date: 2018-07-09 09:38:12 by Tooconservative
Keywords: None
Views: 241
Comments: 2

Justice is coming for unions that forced non-members to pay "non-political" agency fees that went to prop up Democratic candidates. Last month, the Supreme Court ruled that forcing workers who disagree with a union to make these payments anyway violates the workers' First Amendment rights.

Less than a week after that ruling, Janus v. Association of Federal, State, City, and Municipal Employees (FSCME), seven California teachers have filed a class-action lawsuit to recoup unjustly forced fees.

"This lawsuit will enable teachers like me to recover the agency fees that we were wrongly forced to pay against our will," Scott Wilford, the plaintiff in the new lawsuit, told Education Week. Wilford filed the lawsuit in the Central District of California's federal court on Tuesday.

Wilford and six others filed the class-action lawsuit against the National Education Association (NEA), the American Federation of Teachers (AFT) and others. The suit seeks "redress for the defendants' past and ongoing violations of their constitutionally protected rights. The defendants have violated the representative plaintiffs' constitutional rights by, among other things, forcing them to pay fair share service fees as a condition of their employment."

The AFT, like other unions, used "non-political" agency fees for its annual convention in 2016, at which Hillary Clinton spoke.

Wilford and another plaintiff, Rebecca Friedrichs, were also plaintiffs in Friedrichs v. California Teachers Association (2016), a case involving agency fees on which the Supreme Court deadlocked. Janus decided the issue, striking down the 1977 ruling Abood v. Detroit Board of Education, which had allowed unions to collect "non-political" agency fees from non-members in order to prevent workers from becoming "free riders."

In Janus, the Court ruled that workers who refused to join a union because they do not support that union could not be forced to financially support that union anyway. Mark Janus, an Illinois child support staffer, was forced to pay the local union, AFSCME Council 31, even though he refused to join it. AFSCME used the "agency fees" he paid them to support an event hosting Hillary Clinton during the 2016 election.

When Janus struck down mandatory agency fees as unconstitutional, about half of the country — 22 states — had allowed unions to demand agency fees. The AFT recently had 94,000 non-union workers who had to pay agency fees, while the NEA had about 100,000.

The amount that teachers have been charged in agency fees varies, so it is not clear just how much money the plaintiffs are demanding. In any case, it would be a tremendous sum.

AFT President Randi Weingarten told Education Week that this lawsuit is a direct attack on the unions. She argued that it "should be understood for what it is — a bid to ensure workers must fend for themselves and not have the opportunity to live a better life." She also insisted that Janus does not mandate the repayment of fees that these new plaintiffs have demanded.

Matt Frendewey, an education policy consultant and former spokesman for Education Secretary Betsy DeVos, said teachers who refused to join the union are owed this repayment.

Since the Court ruled that agency fees were a violation of public employees' First Amendment rights, this money was "improperly collected" from teachers from the beginning, Frendewey told Education Week. "This is about righting that wrong" and "making those teachers whole by recouping those fees."

Frendewey also predicted that lawsuits would soon be filed in other states affected by the Janus decision.

Nat Malkus, deputy director of education policy studies at the American Enterprise Institute (AEI), told the Daily Caller that this class-action suit is not a First Amendment issue, but a matter of contractual law.

"At the time, everyone was applying with the law," Malkus said. "To make this ruling retroactive, it would be extremely disruptive."

Disruptive or not, unions forcing public employees to pay them, even when those employees disagreed with the union, was fundamentally unjust, and a strong case could be made for restitution.

As Thomas Jefferson wrote in the Virginia Statute for Religious Freedom, "To compel a man to furnish contributions of money for the propagation of opinions which he disbelieves and abhors, is sinful and tyrannical."

The Supreme Court put an end to these ill-gotten gains last month, and Wilford, Friedrichs, and their fellow plaintiffs deserve an apology if nothing more. Wilford and Friedrichs especially deserve something, since their case was blocked for two years by a deadlocked Supreme Court.

Unfortunately, it seems unions are unlikely to give even that, as they staunchly attacked Janus as an unjust decision. Some contrition, and a direct settlement for Wilford and Friedrichs, might save the unions a huge headache — and a multi-million dollar lawsuit. Instead, it seems they're in for the long haul.

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

#1. To: Tooconservative (#0)

Great. Death to unions.

Hank Rearden  posted on  2018-07-09   11:48:47 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#2. To: Hank Rearden (#1)

I'm hoping these people suing them for back dues get a swift judgment. I'd love to see those union warchests depleted before the 2018 midterms.

Even so, the unions will be a lot more tight-fisted with their cash. They know they can't guarantee their ability to refill their coffers from the membership. And some of these unions have a lot of pro-Trump members in them.

It took a few years for the full impact to settle in when Wisconsin did something similar. However, there is a media campaign going now to inform union members that they don't have to keep paying dues if they don't want to. I assume it is funded by the Koch brothers, seems right up their ally.

Tooconservative  posted on  2018-07-09   12:18:47 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Please report web page problems, questions and comments to webmaster@libertysflame.com