[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

FEMA: Trump administration will send ‘presidential alerts’ to cellphones across America

Young Christine Blasey Ford remembered as popular figure in Dewey Beach bar scene in 1980's

Kavanaugh accuser Christine Blasey Ford's team lays out terms it wants for potential Senate interview, sources say

Are Social Media Companies Banning Because Of What Happens In "Real World"? (Face to Face, not online)

COURT DOCUMENTS: Sherrod Brown’s Ex-Wife Accused Him of Assaulting Her

Trump advised Spain to build wall across Sahara to stop migrants

Republicans may 'compel' testimony from Fusion GPS researcher Nellie Ohr, ex-FBI official James Baker

Pope Francis says the devil is causing people to question the Catholic Church

'Family Values' Senator(R) Sentenced to 15 Years for Child Sex Trafficking and Child Porn

Beto O’Rourke to Black American: Illegal Immigrant Labor Needed for Cotton Gin

Kavanaugh Accuser’s Classmate Backs Off Claim She Heard About Alleged Assault

Grassley Ltr to Feinstein Re UNREDACTED Ltr of Christine Blasey Ford (19 Sep 2018)

Pelosi, Schumer, Schiff, Warner Write Letter to Rosenstein, Wray Demanding They Withstand Pressure to Violate DOJ and FBI Norms

Huh. Democrats really don’t want those Carter Page FISA docs released

BOMBSHELL: Comey’s FBI said to have kept TWO sets of records regarding ‘Spygate’ operation

FBI, Justice Dept plan to redact Russia documents despite Trump order for full declassification: report

Ex-CIA Chief John Brennan Encourages Deep State to Defy President Trump’s Declassification Order

The SOBs got to Norm Macdonald

We Need to Stop Scapegoating Third-Party Voters

1 Corinthians 11:28-30

City Forced to Abolish Civil Asset Forfeiture and Pay Back Victims the Millions It Stole from Them

Politicians–Not Hurricanes–Ensure Shortages

LEFT WING NEVER TRUMPER Trump's Tariffs Will Cost More Than Obamacare's Taxes

Prince Harry's Friends Reportedly Have an "Issue" with Meghan Markle

Feinstein under fire for handling of sexual assault allegations against Kavanaugh

Austin man behind 3D-printed gun company charged with sex assault involving minor

Plagiarists Or Innovators? The Led Zeppelin Paradox Endures

The Uglification of America

Kavanaugh- Another Fake Sideshow

As Families Become Outlaws to Treat Epilepsy with Cannabis, Colorado Kids Can Now Bring It To School

Warrants Show Police Never Searched Amber Guyger’s Apartment, Now It’s Too Late, She’s ‘Vacated’ It

2 Hours in Jail for Cop Who Killed Botham Jean. 2 Nights for People Protesting His Death.

Senate panel formally postpones Kavanaugh vote

The Syria Deception: Al-Qaeda Goes to Hollywood (Presidential Globalist Neocon Productions)

Ky. woman tries to avoid arrest by defecating on officer

Suspending the Constitution: In America Today, the Government Does Whatever It Wants

‘Unprecedented’ Government Spending Spree Picks Up Speed

‘Sesame Street’ writer confirms what we all knew about Bert and Ernie

Pedophile's Decapitated Corpse Found On Judge's Doorstep After Bail Hearing In Aurora, Illinois

Syria - Israel Provocation Kills Russian Soldiers - Moscow Will Take Political Revenge

Gun goes off inside Mormon meetinghouse in Provo; church leader is recorded urging teenage girls not to spread news on social media

We Need To Know If Intelligence Agencies Covered Up The 1996 Crash Of TWA 800

Conservative Forced Into Hiding After Writing Pro-Life Tweet

Video Game Treats Cops as Good Guys. The Left is Outraged.

Here Are 202 Companies Hurt by Trump's Tariffs

Allegations throw Kavanaugh confirmation into turmoil (Liars!!!)

Triangle shaped UFO spotted on US Aircraft Carrier in Mediterranean Sea - Space Force?, Leaked Video

Human Rights Campaign honors Raytheon for LGBT equality

The Dike Breaks - Netherland Ends Support For 'White Helmets' Terrorist Propaganda

Les Wexner renounces Republican Party affiliation


Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

United States News
See other United States News Articles

Title: Two (or Three) Kinds of Honesty - Trump is hyper-intensely himself.
Source: Splice Today
URL Source: https://www.splicetoday.com/politic ... /two-or-three-kinds-of-honesty
Published: Jul 23, 2018
Author: Crispin Sartwell
Post Date: 2018-08-15 07:25:59 by Deckard
Keywords: None
Views: 30
Comments: 1

Donald Trump is dishonest in a variety of ways. Much of what he says is false or skewed. Sometimes he flatly contradicts himself, which honest people try to avoid on the grounds that it’s logically impossible to contradict oneself and speak the truth throughout. If I were considering a business transaction with Trump, I wouldn’t be entirely secure that he was going to do what he said, or even what he committed himself to do by contract.

But if you talk to Trump supporters here in rural Pennsylvania, it doesn’t take much time for them to say that what they like best is that he’s so much more honest than other politicians. I’ve heard this opinion explained by the alleged facts that Trump supporters rely exclusively on Fox News, that they’re credulous and ignorant, that they, unlike the people doing the talking, don’t care about what’s actually true or false, but only about nursing their resentments. In other words, if people say he’s honest, it must be because they believe what he says. But in a perfectly good sense, they’re right about Trump’s honesty even though the man is no scrupulous truth-teller.

There are different forms of honesty as a virtue. One kind of honesty is a matter of saying true things and not saying false ones, as best one can. At its maximum, this sort of honesty constitutes the courage to speak the truth under difficult circumstances, or in the face of a hostile world. In the case of politicians, diplomats, and press secretaries, however, that sort of sentence-by-sentence honesty often gets interpreted as a quasi-moral imperative not to say anything demonstrably false. For example, Sean Spicer could’ve avoided trouble by fudging on inaugural crowd sizes instead of making clear claims. One way to not say false things is to say as little as possible, even as one continues to emit words, which is the opposite of courage.

Another dimension of honesty, however, might be described as a willingness to reveal yourself publicly, to show truly who you are or what you really believe, a resolution not to conceal oneself. One might connect this to a nexus of related virtues: integrity (a kind of coherence or singleness of self), sincerity, and a certain sort of presence in one’s own words and actions. In this sense Trump is notably more honest than any presidential-level politician in the modern era. He reveals himself.

The public personae created by Al Gore, John Kerry, Mitt Romney, Hillary Clinton, and Barack Obama as they ran for president were almost interchangeable: they appeared in the guise of carefully engineered quasi-persons speaking in focus-grouped catch phrases, often the same ones. “President” was a role these people aspired to play on television, and each of them produced the words that emerged from the attempt to enact the role. In such cases, public and private selves become separated or even opposed, and you have to speculate about what such apparent people really believe, what they say when they don’t think anyone’s listening, or what’s going on in their lives. They appear in public as pseudo-persons, Westworld hosts simulating consciousness with mixed success.

By way of extreme contrast, Trump is hyper-intensely himself. One of his biggest alleged offenses is that he does not act “presidential”; rather he acts like a human of a certain sort. He gets mad and he lets fly. He parades his insecurities and crows about his accomplishments. The flaws are all right there because he’s all right there. Waves of emotion wash through his Twitter feed, as they do through an actual human body.

Hillary Clinton has plenty of flaws too, though I’m sure hers are rather different. But she has devoted her life to concealing these flaws, to concealing herself. This was once conceived to be an absolute necessity in politics, and candidates would hire people or try to generate algorithms to shape their personhood, to hone their phraseology, to help them manufacture a glittering yet uncontroversial public self that could be released like a mylar balloon into the stratosphere of political power.

Trump has dispensed with all of that. Not that he isn’t conscious of creating a public image, but he doesn’t let his staff or pollsters do it for him: he’s the creator of himself. Second, he’s about as conscious of his public persona as he can be. At a news conference discussing negotiations with Kim Jong-un he said, characteristically, “I think, honestly, I think he’s going to do these things. I may be wrong. I mean, I may stand before you in six months and say, ‘Hey, I was wrong.’ I don’t know that I’ll ever admit that, but I’ll find some kind of an excuse.”

As Trump reveals himself, you may be disturbed by or even hate what you see, and want to vote for or be governed by anything else. The reality of Trump might make you pine even for the unreality of the automata, and it might make you yearn for honesty in the sense of speaking the truth, or even honesty in the sense of failing to say anything false by failing to say anything. Or you may love the extreme Trumpiness of Trump, or think it’s all a mixed bag, and so on. But at least we can all see, in all media all the time, the actual person we’re actually endorsing or rejecting. 

—Follow Crispin Sartwell on Twitter: @CrispinSartwell

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

#1. To: Deckard (#0)

Good article.

And a further point - I do not accept that, on most things, we actually KNOW the truth to be able to truly judge whether somebody is telling it or not. In general it is: "I believe this to be true. He says something else. Therefore, he is a liar. Or he is deluded." Of course, if the belief that the judger has in such a case is itself wrong, or delusional, then the "lie" of the other may ACTUALLY be the truth, in an absolute sense.

Absolute truths are hard to know. More usually, both sides of every argument have SOME truth, mixed with falsehood and fantasy, but they don't recognize this.

Vicomte13  posted on  2018-08-15   8:30:06 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Please report web page problems, questions and comments to webmaster@libertysflame.com