[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Joe Bonamassa - This Train - Live At The Sydney Opera House - Anyone recognize the piano intro?

Polling Average: Trump's Approval Rating Higher Than Obama's at This Point In Presidency

The GOP Briefing Room

U.S. Contains Enough Oil and Gas Reserves to Fuel Country for Decades, Petroleum Institute Says

The Original Rock 'n' Roll Guitar God Was Actually a Goddess

North Carolina High School Teacher: VP Mike Pence Should be “Shot in the Head”

Detroit Police Sued Yet Again for Shooting a Woman's Dogs During a Warrantless Search

France: The High Court condemns political commentator Eric Zemmour for telling the truth about Islamic invasion

13 Marines charged for smuggling undocumented immigrants into the U.S.

A Michigan Man Has Been Acquitted by a Jury for Criticizing a County Judge on Facebook

Pigeon poops on state lawmaker as he gives TV interview about pigeon poop problem

Jon Rappoport — My Memories From The Fake News Business

Court Shoots Down Cop's Assertion That Driving Without Breaking Any Laws Is 'Suspicious'

Those who believe offical government narratives are the real "kooks".

NBC Asks the Public to Confess Their Climate Sins

Why can’t we agree on what’s true any more?

The Clintons, Laura Silsby, Haiti, Amber Alerts & Human Trafficking

POLITICS [VIDEO] LOL: CNN Goes to Minnesota and Discovers Most Democrats Are Now Trump Supporters

Prozac Maker Paid Millions To Secure Favourable Verdict In Mass Shooting Lawsuit

New Epstein Victim Implicates Biden, McCain, "others in the White House today.“"

The Very Book The Government Does Not Want You To Read Just Went #1 In The World

Jersey City cops shown on video kicking innocent man lose jobs, avoid jail time

Woman struggling with mental illness was fatally shot in her home after Henrico police went to check on her

'Total Massacre' as U.S. Drone Strike Kills 30 Farmers in Afghanistan

Police had a citizen set up a sting to buy back his stolen stuff. Then, they didn’t show up.

9/11 mystery: Contradictory witness accounts left out by official report - 'no accident'

This Awful House Bill Would Promote Gun Confiscation Without Due Process

Hamburg 1948 - Rare Footage in color and HD

The Cheka - Lenin´s Red Terror! English subtitles.

Does the Religious Left Know What Lenin Said About Christians and Socialism? There's no escaping it: Socialism is anti-Christian.

9/11: Short And Powerful Questions

The Deep State Vs The 2nd Amendment

'Only plausible candidate': Never Trump Republicans plotting to back Biden

Ford's Friend Told NYT Scribes She Didn’t Believe Kavanaugh Allegations

Trump says EPA to issue notice to San Francisco on homeless

Stevie Ray Vaughan - Little Wing/Third Stone from the sun

Lawsuit Settlement Over Detainment Of A Journalist Will Force Denver Police Department To Admit The First Amendment Exists

Ninth Circuit Upholds Its Previous Declaration That Cops Stealing Your Stuff Doesn't Violate The Constitution

Say That Again, I WILL Kick Your Ass

Revenge of the Baseball Nerds

Navy Confirms Authenticity of UFO Videos Published by Blink-182 Frontman's Extraterrestrial Research Organization

Warren captures big endorsement from former Bernie supporters

‘My AR is Ready’

The Red Flag Council

Trump Tweets on Iran and NSA

Ilhan Omar Just Deleted A Tweet From 2013. Here's What It Said.

It’s all a scam: Al Gore a major investor in fake meat company while pushing fake climate science scare over real meat

REPORT: Trump To Kill House-Passed Universal Background Check Bill

Oxycontin Maker Files For Bankruptcy After Funneling Billions Into Private Accounts

Tulsi Gabbard Slams Trump: Being “Saudi Arabia’s Bitch is Not America First”

Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

United States News
See other United States News Articles

Title: Court Rules Cop Who Shot Unarmed 15-Year-Old Is Protected by Qualified Immunity
Source: Reason
URL Source: https://reason.com/2019/08/22/court ... otected-by-qualified-immunity/
Published: Aug 22, 2019
Author: Billy Binion
Post Date: 2019-08-23 08:05:00 by Deckard
Keywords: None
Views: 19

The ruling once again shows the legal disgrace that is qualified immunity.


(Ivansabo | Dreamstime.com)

A panel of judges for the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit has ruled that an officer with the Los Angeles Police Department (LAPD) is protected by qualified immunity after shooting a 15-year-old boy as he made his way to school. The decision joins a towering pile of case law upholding a legal doctrine that protects government officials from facing civil suits for actions that would land a regular person in the clink.

In February 2015, four teenagers convened near their school, forming a tight circle to dance and listen to rap music, as was their ritual prior to attending classes. Shortly after they turned off the music and began to prepare for class, Officer Michael Gutierrez fired into the crowd, striking Jamar Nicholson Green in the back. Another teen, Michael Sanders, was holding a plastic Airsoft gun replica with a bright orange tip; Gutierrez says he mistook it for a real weapon and believed Sanders was pointing it at another teen in the circle, Jason Huerta.

All four teens say that Gutierrez, who was not wearing a uniform, did not identify himself, nor did he give them verbal warnings to drop the toy gun.

After shooting Green, Gutierrez and additional officers on the scene held the teens at gunpoint, face down on the ground. The teens explained that the gun was fake, but the officers still handcuffed the teens and detained them for five hours—even Huerta, who Gutierrez said he believed to be a potential victim. Green remained in handcuffs as he underwent a medical examination.

The panel for the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit wrote in summary that the shooting violated Green's due process rights. "Under the circumstances, a rational finder of fact could find that Gutierrez's use of deadly force shocked the conscience and was unconstitutional under the Fourteenth Amendment," they said. Even so, "the panel held that because no analogous case existed at the time of the shooting, the district court erred by denying Gutierrez qualified immunity for this claim."

In essence, because a similar case has not yet rendered a ruling applicable to Gutierrez's actions, the judges ruled that those actions were protected by qualified immunity. The decision echoes a recent one in Georgia, where the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit ruled that Coffee County Sheriff's Deputy Matthew Vickers was shielded from recourse after shooting a 10-year-old child in the knee while trying to shoot a non-threatening dog.

Both cases demonstrate the maddening nature of qualified immunity: State actors cannot be held to account unless a related precedent exists. But can how such a precedent come to be when civil servants keep hiding behind qualified immunity?

The 9th Circuit did, however, deny Gutierrez legal shielding for the teens' 5-hour handcuffed detainment, which they said blatantly violated their Fourth Amendment rights. Writing for the majority, Judge Jacqueline Nguyen said that a jury should hear the case.

"We agree with the district court that under these circumstances, plaintiffs' continued detention for five hours—well after any probable cause would have dissipated—and the use of handcuffs throughout the duration of the detention violated plaintiffs' clearly established Fourth Amendment rights to be free from unlawful arrest and excessive force," she said.

(2 images)

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  

[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Please report web page problems, questions and comments to webmaster@libertysflame.com